Re: Disk vs. Disc
By John A. Tuttle
Hi all,
Just for grins I looked in the back of David Bowers' "Encyclopedia of Automatic Musical Instruments", in the dictionary of Automatic Musical Instrument terms. The word "disc" does not appear. However, under the definition of the word "disc" the last two sentences read, "Also spelled as 'disk.' Synonyms [not in popular usage with collectors today]: record, tune sheet."
On the other hand, on page 143 there are two ads for Olympia self- playing music boxes, and both of the ads use the spelling "disk".
Further, in all the ads I could locate, Regina and Stella called them "tune sheets".
Finally, from the little research I did on the matter, I never saw the word "disc" in the ads of the day. Does anybody have any old ads that use that spelling? Seems to me that may put an end to the discussion. Then we could say, "Stop, we're -all_ right." Maybe we can make up a new name for those "round, metal, circular shaped things with the tiny holes or protrusions all over them."
The questions that come to my mind are: Does it really make any difference? Exactly where is the point of confusion? If the original makers couldn't decide what to call them how are _we_ ever going to come to a conclusion that everyone can agree on?
Call them what you like. If someone disagrees, that's their prerogative.
Musically, John Tuttle
[ Ed. Note: Thanks for the research, John. The evidence you present --
[ the Olympia advertisements -- indicates that "disk" was the common
[ spelling at the time, and this is in agreement with the entries in
[ American dictionaries. We, nowadays, can surely use either
[ spelling without confusion. -- Robbie
|
(Message sent Mon 2 Sep 1996, 15:25:16 GMT, from time zone GMT-0400.) |
|
|
Mechanical
Music Digest™ Archives
