MMD > Archives > September 1996 > 1996.09.26 > 11Prev  Next


Two Notes for the Price of One
By John A. Tuttle

Hi Darrell,

My first inclination would be any of the junction blocks where the
tracker tubes go through. Sometimes a "cross-leak" will develop
especially if there is a screw close by. The most suspect area is the
connection between the upper and lower half of the upper section.

I guess one question would be, is the problem bi-directional?  (If
opening "C" activates "D", does opening "D" activate "C"?) Another very
important piece of information is Exactly which notes are involved. If
they are adjacent, I would suspect wood or gasket leakage. If they are,
in fact, separated by one note then I would be inclined to suspect a
crack between the two pouch chambers.

Does it happen all the time? If you reduce the vacuum to minimum do
they both come on with equal strength? And at higher vacuum levels?

Although it would be an odd problem, it is possible that the pouches
are actually cross-leaking. Imagine that in the area where the two
edges of the pouch touch each other, or overlap, that the glue on the
pouch closest to the wood has come slightly unglued. When either note
is activated, as the pouch puffs up, it "blows" some air under the edge
of the pouch into the other chamber. If that is the case, then lowering
the vacuum level to minimum would show that the offending note comes
"on" slower even if only by a few milliseconds and visa- versa. Here
again, I would use smoke to test. I'd blow smoke in one hole and see if
it comes back out the other. I suppose you could do the same thing with
air but it's hard to see air.

One last thing. Take a suck tube and place it over a known good note.
Alternately suck and blow on the tube until you have a good "feel" for
the resistance to air flow. Then try the same test on the bad notes. If
the resistance factor is greater when you suck "out" than when you blow
"in" (as compared to the good note), then the problem is most likely
the seal around the pouch.

All this said, personally I would just remove the pouch board and
physically examine the pouches to eliminate the possibility that the
pouches aren't glued down well enough, first. You could also examine
the gaskets and the screw holes at that point.

One problem just came to mind that caused exactly the same problem but
the notes were adjacent, not separated by a note. If you have ever had
to "repair" a stripped screw on the "j" block between the upper and
lower half of the upper section, and you put something down the hole to
"fill up" the space, there is a good chance that the wood cracked and
pushed a bit of the wood into one of the tracker holes. To remedy this
problem (which I've seen many times) I take one-third of the newer type
plastic "Y" connectors (which are a few micro-inches larger that the
standard tracker hole size) and glue it into the tracker hole on the
pouch board. In this case, you have to remove the "j" block between the
two halves of the upper section of the pouch board.

Well, that's all I have to say. Good luck and let me know how you make
out.

Musically, John Tuttle¶
•---------------------------------------------------------------------------
John A Tuttle "Self-Playing Pianos"    E-mail:tuttleja@concentric.net
407 19th Avenue                             908-840-8787 (leave message)
Bricktown, NJ 08724               Rolls:1-800-870-8784 (leave order)
"We Keep Your Music Rolling"  http://www.concentric.net/~tuttleja/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Message sent Thu, 26 Sep 1996 17:48:46 -0400 (EDT) , from time zone -0400.)

Key Words in Subject:  Notes, One, Price, Two

Related by Subject:
1996.09.26.11 (This article) - Two Notes for the Price of One
2022.07.17.04 - Seek Transfer of Two Old Piano Rolls to MIDI Files
from Ben Roth
2020.12.28.03 - Seek "Two Loves Have I" Piano Roll
from Robert Bartlett
2019.12.08.05 - FS Free: Two Player Pianos in Florida
from Clark Wheeler
2019.03.10.02 - "Liberty Bell" By Sousa As A Two Step vs. March
from Wallace Venable
2019.03.09.02 - Sousa "Liberty Bell" as Two Step vs. March
from Andrew Lardieri
2018.09.29.02 - Seek Two Ampico Rolls
from Mike Walter
2018.08.27.02 - FS: Small Blower & Two Ampico Pumps
from Bill Chapman
2018.08.13.07 - Adjusting Aeolian Two-Ear Roll Tracking System
from John Grant
2018.08.10.06 - Adjusting Aeolian Two-Ear Roll Tracking System
from John A. Tuttle
2018.08.09.03 - Adjusting Aeolian Two-Ear Roll Tracking System
from Don Teach
2018.08.09.04 - Adjusting Aeolian Two-Ear Roll Tracking System
from John Grant