MMD > Archives > April 1997 > 1997.04.09 > 11Prev  Next


Late vs. Early Duo-Art Pianos
By Les Smith

Mike, It's just a personal opinion, but if I were you, I'd be happy with
the earlier version of the Duo-Art mechanism found on your Steck grand.
The so-called "Very Late" version has been greatly over-rated, probably
because of its relative rarity.  Yes, it did have an electric roll-drive
motor, a la the Ampico B; and all the tubing was routed to two large
spring-clamps at either end, which greatly facilitated the removal of the
piano action for servicing; and all the control -- such as they were --
were located in the spoolbox.  All well and good.

However, the price one paid for this break-through technology was the
loss of all the individual, hand-controlled expression levers found in
earlier versions of the D-A, which allowed you to add your own expression
to the rolls being played and thus become a part of the music-making
process, rather than just remaining merely an observer and listener.

If all you want to do is to listen to a reproducing piano play, then you
might just as well buy some recordings of one and save yourself the time
and expense of rebuilding and maintaining one.  OTOH, if you want to
become part of the music making process, that is inject part of yourself
into the music being played, then you'll probably be happier with the
type of D-A mechanism found in your piano.

Some people are undoubtedly happy just to sit back an listen to the music
being played, but I have always considered one of the main fascinations
with the player piano to be the fact that it could make a de facto
pianist out of someone who didn't play, by allowing them to participate
in the performance of a piece via the expression and tempo controls.
Just one old tech's opinion, of course!

Les Smith
lessmith@buffnet.net



(Message sent Wed, 9 Apr 1997 21:47:47 -0400 (EDT) , from time zone -0400.)

Key Words in Subject:  Duo-Art, Early, Late, Pianos, vs

Related by Subject:
1997.04.09.11 (This article) - Late vs. Early Duo-Art Pianos
2024.12.04.02 - FS: Late Seeburg E Nickelodeon in So. California
from Marc Sachnoff
2024.05.25.01 - Late '20s Aeolian Player Piano Leaking Badly
from Piotr Barcz
2023.07.29.03 - Odd Action Stack Valve in Late Ampico 'A'
from John A. Tuttle
2023.02.25.01 - FS: Late Seeburg KT, Eagle Glass, in Kentucky
from Mikey Mills
2023.01.31.03 - FS: Late Ampico A in Cleveland
from Ann Donoghue
2023.01.01.02 - Seek Picture of Late 1930s Cable Player Piano
from Ben Roth
2021.10.22.01 - Unknown Tune On Late 19th-century Cylinder Box
from Bill Chapman
2021.10.19.01 - Unknown Tune On Late 19th-century Cylinder Box
from Bill Wineburgh
2020.05.21.01 - FS: Knabe Late A Ampico Art Case in Washington
from Thomas Binnall
2019.09.09.05 - Late Duo-Art Organ Rolls Show Declining Quality
from Bob Taylor
2019.04.08.01 - Seek Tubing Diagram For Very Late Duo-Art Grand
from Benjamin Haass