MMD > Archives > November 1999 > 1999.11.15 > 11Prev  Next


Single-Finger Music Roll Tracking System
By Craig Brougher

Realizing that I forgot to mention the way I fix tracker systems that
don't have cutouts, I might add this suggestion.

Mike Kitner had a good idea, I thought.  A mechanical "lock", which
is probably a pneumatic with a finger extending backward from its hinge
to press against the tracker pneumatic, bringing it approximately to
the center position.

The problem with any tracking system on reroll is in trying to get
a roll back safely when the tracker had to track the roll at its
extremes.  Today, the best rolls are in the worst possible condition
because they're the ones played most often.  So your most valuable
rolls are the most vulnerable.  These problems weren't apparent when
some of the mechanisms were first designed.  So to add a helper
pneumatic or cutout and spring that improves the roll's chances of
survival is a very important suggestion.

The Standard Action Player and others have a flat spring that gradually
returns the bellows all the way up and sends the roll core all the way
to the left.  That would tend to cause the roll to pile up on the right
"fixed" roll flange, except that the weight of the cam arm is down, so
the overall effect it a very slow recentering movement.

The later Aeolians cut off the tracker finger ports to the dual tracker
bellows and left the vacuum on, so that if the bellows were equally
airtight, the system would center itself quickly and stay rigid.
However, this system for some reason tends to tear more rolls on rewind
than the Standard, possibly because it immediately centers, whereas the
Standard Action begins at the extreme it was brought to by the roll and
very slowly returns.  That makes more sense to me.

So for my tastes, a centering device like Mike Kitner recommends --
with a bleed in its supply connected to the motor governor line where
the vacuum is still regulated and won't be overwhelmed by a suction box
-- is a good idea (depending on how large you make your pneumatic, of
course).  And the vacuum line originally connected to the tracker
pneumatic should be stack (playing) vacuum instead of coming directly
from the pump.  These players usually don't have Themodists, anyway.

One other small suggestion as a touch would be that you try a flat
spring in place of a rigid centering finger so the tracker can be
centered gradually.

Craig Brougher



(Message sent Mon, 15 Nov 1999 07:01:56 -0600 , from time zone -0600.)

Key Words in Subject:  Music, Roll, Single-Finger, System, Tracking

Related by Subject:
1999.11.15.11 (This article) - Single-Finger Music Roll Tracking System
2024.07.01.01 - Regina 27" Dragon Front Single Door Changer Gear
from Jere Ryder
2024.06.30.01 - Regina 27" Dragon Front Single Door Changer Gear
from Alan Recce
2024.01.03.02 - Single Copy Piano Roll Perforator For Home Use
from Spencer Chase
2023.03.17.02 - Spinet Ampico A With Single Crescendo Unit
from Eli Shahar
2019.07.01.02 - 1910 Single-Valve Standard Pneumatic Action
from Nate Otto
2018.11.29.03 - FS: 1914 Single Mills Violano in New York
from Robert Hanulec
2017.12.13.02 - Early Example of Single Comb Construction
from Mark Singleton
2017.10.01.02 - Converting Double-Valve Action to Single-Valve
from Luke Myers
2016.09.24.05 - FS: Standard Single-valve Player Piano
from Ben Roth
2013.09.03.03 - FS: Amphion Single Valve Player Action Stack
from Bruce Ahlich
2012.01.25.06 - Switching Repeating- to Single-stroke Xylophone
from Clay Hinrichs