MMD > Archives > March 2000 > 2000.03.19 > 15Prev  Next


Limitations of MIDI
By Stephen Kent Goodman

Art Reblitz wrote, "I can only attribute this to the serial MIDI
data stream getting constipated."

Using an old version of Cakewalk as a program of origination, and
played through an Octet controller which is connected to a reliable
magnet to pneumatic interface, it has been my experience that not only
is NO data lost, but all notes are right on the tempo.  Please refer
to the Blessing Robot Band, which sometimes uses 4-handed piano
arrangements, percussion, and register/expression controls without so
much as a late beat.

The tremendous accuracy of and ease of getting music into an instrument
is my only interest in MIDI.  To my knowledge, no one has scored
directly on MIDI for as large of instrument (in terms of number of
notes played/figure controls, etc.) as I have and my comments are based
on my actual experience.  And all along I was looking for shortcomings!

Cheers,
Stephen Kent Goodman



(Message sent Sun, 19 Mar 2000 09:45:24 -0800 , from time zone -0800.)

Key Words in Subject:  Limitations, MIDI

Related by Subject:
2010.09.17.05 - Limitations of a Player Piano
from Paul Morris
2010.09.16.03 - Limitations of a Player Piano
from Tom Sendall
2000.03.24.04 - Limitations of MIDI
from Richard Stibbons
2000.03.19.13 - Limitations of MIDI
from Richard Stibbons
2000.03.19.14 - Limitations of MIDI
from Tony Decap
2000.03.19.15 (This article) - Limitations of MIDI
from Stephen Kent Goodman
2000.03.19.16 - Limitations of MIDI
from John Wale
2000.03.19.17 - Limitations of MIDI Systems
from Richard Brandle
2000.03.18.04 - Limitations of MIDI
from Art Reblitz
2000.03.17.03 - Limitations of MIDI Control
from Robbie Rhodes
2000.03.16.02 - Limitations of MIDI Control
from Douglas Henderson