MMD > Archives > December 2013 > 2013.12.18 > 01Prev  Next


"The Nutcracker" Played on Ampico & Duo-Art
By Ralph Nielsen

As a contribution to the long-standing comparison of Ampico and
Duo-Art reproducing piano systems, I have just posted two videos
of selections from Tchaikovsky's "The Nutcracker".  Both videos show
recently restored instruments, captured with the same microphones
and recording equipment.  The Duo-Art version is here:

  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jK-xoOL1ShQ
Attachment thumbnail and the Ampico version is here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QybqhcPRHBI
Attachment thumbnail As a restorer and a fan of both systems, I am not inclined to pick one above the other. Hopefully the videos show that the performance capabilities of both systems are quite similar, when in reasonably well-maintained condition. But the differences are also clear, including first the instruments available with each system (in this case Mason & Hamlin vs. Steinway). Second is the pneumatic and expression control logic ("power division" vs. positive air pressure regulation, "lock and cancel" vs. continuous level control, theme/accompaniment control vs. bass/treble control). Third is configuration and maintenance requirements (i.e., drawer mount vs. "through the keyboard"). And fourth is clearly the different musical selections, arrangements and recorded artists available for the two systems (in this case, Frank Sheridan in February 1929 vs. Percy Grainger in October 1924). Happy Holidays, and happy listening! Ralph Nielsen http://www.historicpianos.com/

(Message sent Tue, 17 Dec 2013 23:56:07 -0800 (PST) , from time zone -0800.)

Key Words in Subject:  Ampico, Duo-Art, Nutcracker, Played