MMD > Archives > December 1998 > 1998.12.19 > 16Prev  Next


Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
By Dean Randall

Seasonal Felicitations all,  Am I missing something?

> If the last digit is omitted, the roll numbers are in (approximate)
> chronological order.  That is what is being proposed.  Thus, Ampico
> Roll No. 70301, "The Flight of the Bumblebee," played by Sergei Rach-
> maninoff, would become Roll No. 7030.  Roll No. 67673 would become
> 6767, and so forth.

Even without dropping the size digit, the Ampico roll numbers are in
approximate chronological order within their series.  What would be the
advantage of dropping the final digit?  I would guess that by this time,
every Ampico roll collector knows that the final digit denotes roll
size, no?

Starting with Flight of the Bumblebee, the sequence is now:

70301, 70313, 70323, 70331, etc.  MS Access sorts just fine this way,
and I have no trouble putting them on my shelves with the numbers
complete.

To those of us who are dyed-in-the-wool collectors, I see possible
confusion arising by elimination of the size digit.  For example, in
the dated number series, # 101053 (Marche Slav, Op. 31) would then
become 10105.

Still with me?

101055, Dance Music Series, Pgm. Number 18, with the size digit
eliminated would also become 10105.

Unless the roll title follows the number, I wouldn't know which roll
was being referenced in a case such as this.

What am I failing to understand about this proposal?

Dean Randall
In 22 degree weather (!) on Puget Sound
pianolists@earthlink.net



(Message sent Sat, 19 Dec 1998 23:09:03 -0800 , from time zone -0800.)

Key Words in Subject:  Ampico, Numbers, Proposal, Roll, Shortened

Related by Subject:
2009.04.09.03 - Piano Roll Search Service Proposal
from Paul Eggert
2009.04.08.03 - Piano Roll Search Service Proposal
from Mike Morrey
2007.03.11.02 - Perforator Project Proposal
from Richard Friedman
2005.03.31.02 - Proposal for Band Organ Rally in North Carolina
from Tommy Forney
1998.12.21.05 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Dave Saul
1998.12.20.06 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from D. L. Bullock
1998.12.20.07 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Dan Wilson, London
1998.12.19.12 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Richard Stibbons
1998.12.19.13 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Bruce Clark
1998.12.19.14 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Paul Johnson
1998.12.19.15 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Mike Walter
1998.12.19.16 (This article) - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Dean Randall