MMD > Archives > July 2013 > 2013.07.03 > 01Prev  Next


Copyright Warning at YouTube
By T. J. Fisher

I believe YouTube uses automated systems to detect when music in its
videos matches music in some database(s) of presumably-copyrighted
music.  (Remember that even if a composition is out of [composer]
copyright, a performance of may still be under [performance]
copyright).

Perhaps YouTube has incorrectly matched your video to some recording of
another piece.  Is there, I wonder, some system by which you can answer
YouTube's warning?

For the record, I don't think "50 years after the death of the composer
and/or performer" is right in America, although it may be in the UK.
There have, I believe, been changes to our copyright law executed after
heavy lobbying from money-grubbers.  Somebody else is surely more
qualified to answer that element of your question.  As far as I'm
concerned, purchasing a music roll does give one performance rights.
Whether the copyright office agrees is another question, I guess!

TJ Fisher



(Message sent Wed, 3 Jul 2013 07:54:03 -0700 (PDT) , from time zone -0700.)

Key Words in Subject:  Copyright, Warning, YouTube

Related by Subject:
2013.07.03.01 (This article) - Copyright Warning at YouTube
2021.08.08.02 - Aeolian Organ Roll Copyright Stamps
from Kevin McElhone
2021.02.13.03 - YouTube Copyright Claims
from Christian Tedesco
2021.02.12.03 - YouTube Copyright Claims
from Art Thompson
2020.06.14.02 - Ampico Roll Date and Copyright Status
from Roger Wiegand
2015.09.24.03 - "Happy Birthday" Copyright Claims Ruled Invalid
from Matthew Caulfield
2015.09.23.02 - "Happy Birthday" Copyright Claims Ruled Invalid
from Robbie Rhodes
2014.08.14.04 - Rich Olsen Wurlitzer Rolls Copyright Status
from Gordon Ramsey
2013.07.12.01 - Copyright Warning at YouTube
from George Bogatko
2013.07.11.02 - Copyright Warning at YouTube
from Paddy Handscombe
2013.07.11.01 - Piano Roll Music Copyright vs. Public Domain
from Matthew Caulfield
2013.07.10.02 - Copyright Warning at YouTube
from Gordon Stelter