MMD > Archives > February 2021 > 2021.02.12 > 03Prev  Next


YouTube Copyright Claims
By Art Thompson

YouTube being YouTube (again)

For those who publish videos of their instruments on YouTube, this
might be of interest. I'm not sure if others have had this issue,
but from time to time YouTube's copyright bot will place a copyright
claim on one or more of my videos.

I'm always careful to make sure everything I post is Public Domain,
but none-the-less I will invariably get a claim on things like "Over
the Waves", or "Sweet Rosie O'Grady", and such. I normally just dispute
the claim with a few insults regarding the intelligence (or lack
thereof) of the claimant, and after thirty days it goes away.

However, just today I got another claim on "Over the Waves" so I
decided to find the music that I was allegedly infringing, just to see
how stupid YouTube's copyright ID bot was.

To my surprise, the intro to a heavy metal album entitled "Carnival of
Killers" featured about thirty seconds of my Wurlitzer 145B playing
"Over the Waves". Apparently the band (which was appropriately named
"Macabre"), had taken the audio from my video clip and incorporated it
into their album.

My video: https://youtu.be/Tdic3gbcs4o
Attachment thumbnail Their album: https://youtu.be/FaaxxzpyNNk
Attachment thumbnail This album is not exactly my taste in music (if it can be even called that). However, it is apparently somewhat popular in its genre, so I guess I should be flattered that out of all of the organs on YouTube playing that piece, they chose mine. But for me to get a copyright claim for them using _my_ work is a bit irritating. Of course I sent a relatively polite email to their record company reminding them that they should get permission before using someone else's work, even if it is just recording a video. Any thoughts? Art Thompson art@vfcm.org.geentroep [delete ".geentroep" to reply]

(Message sent Thu, 11 Feb 2021 22:14:21 -0800 (PST) , from time zone -0800.)

Key Words in Subject:  Claims, Copyright, YouTube

Related by Subject:
2021.02.12.03 (This article) - YouTube Copyright Claims
2025.11.05.01 - Ronald Olsen's YouTube Channel Recordings
from Piotr Barcz
2025.08.19.01 - Seek Dave Haibach, YouTube "PianoSynCrazy"
from Piotr Barcz
2024.07.27.01 - MBSGB Launches New Website and YouTube Channel
from Kevin McElhone
2023.12.20.01 - "Oh Come Little Children" 13" Kalliope on YouTube
from Jochen Schäfer
2023.01.02.01 - MechaMusica New Year's Concert 2023 on YouTube
from Johnny Claes
2022.12.31.01 - 'The Close of the Year' 13" Kalliope on YouTube
from Jochen Schäfer
2022.12.23.01 - Christmas and More, New on YouTube
from Jochen Schäfer
2022.12.12.02 - Player Piano Restoration Video Series on YouTube
from Nate Otto
2022.10.31.02 - YouTube Channel Featuring 1928 Themola Piano
from Piotr Barcz
2022.10.31.01 - MechaMusica New Year's Concert on YouTube
from Johnny Claes
2022.10.27.02 - Mechanical Music History Video at YouTube
from Ed Chaban