MMD > Archives > October 1996 > 1996.10.05 > 06Prev  Next


Re: Advertising Items for Sale in the Digest
By Marc Kaufman

> "Hal O'Rourke" writes:
>
> I'm somewhat surprised that you are allowing advertising of items for
> sale in the Digest. I just assumed that it was for the exchange of
> information, and not for `want ads.'
>
> I suggest there be a clear statement of policy on this issue (and then
> enforce the policy). My vote would be to not allow advertising as it
> can easily get out of hand. My one exception would be for people
> looking for obscure parts.
>
> What do you other people think???

The digest is whatever we want it to be (IMHO). Since Jody is not
"sponsored" by AMICA, MBSI, ATOS or whatever, there is no conflict of
interest or prohibition by by-laws with respect to advertising. It's
been a long time since "Acceptable Use" policies controlled the
majority of the internet.

I read this digest for a variety of reasons -- technical content,
reports of interesting instruments and, yes, the messages that
advertise items related to automatic music. I hope the list will be
used to bring this information together in one place rather than make
us go to yet another list (Automatic- Music-Ads ?) for commercial and
private advertising.

There is enough moderation in the list to ensure that advertising will
not be abusive.

There are people who feel that even compilations of lists, such as the
sources for rolls and the growing list of sources for monkey organs, is
"advertising".  I think that information that benefits the readers
(users) of the list is fair game for the list -- even if a side effect
is to give a free ad to some supplier.



(Message sent Wed, 25 Sep 1996 07:39:28 -0800 , from time zone -0800.)

Key Words in Subject:  Advertising, Digest, Items, Sale

Related by Subject:
1996.10.05.06 (This article) - Re: Advertising Items for Sale in the Digest
2018.09.21.01 - Coin-Op & Advertising Auction Chicago Sept. 29th
from Gabe Fajuri
2015.09.02.03 - Autumn Advertising in MGSGB Journal
from Mark Singleton
2013.08.25.05 - FS: QRS Store Advertising Card
from Jerry F. Bacon
2011.12.01.10 - FS: Dynavoice Keytop Player Advertising Leaflet
from Richard Friedman
2009.03.02.02 - QRS Artists in QRS Advertising
from Mark Forer
2007.08.30.02 - Advertising Site for Non-player Organs & Pianos
from Philip Jamison
2007.08.29.02 - Advertising Site for Non-player Organs & Pianos
from Joyce Brite
2001.05.08.04 - Old Aeolian Advertising in Artcraft Newsletter
from Douglas Henderson
1999.09.02.05 - Advertising at MMD
from Beatrice Robertson
1999.09.02.06 - Advertising at MMD
from John Dewey
1999.09.02.07 - Advertising at MMD
from Terry Smythe