MMD > Archives > November 1996 > 1996.11.30 > 09Prev  Next


Re: G rolls classical
By Stephen Kent Goodman

In a message dated 96-11-29 04:01:53 EST, you write:

>
> Did they ever produce G rolls with Serious "classical music"?  I
> realize that in the 1920s coin op environment there would probably have
> been little demand, but were not some Orchestrions built for home use?
> No recut catalogue seems to have any.
>
>

The closest thing that I have seen is an "Operatic Selections" G roll
that I seldom if ever played.  Somehow, themes from "I Pagliaci" and
"Il Trovatore" doesn't seem to fit the sound of piano, mandolin,
xylophone and drums.  I would imagine the WurliTzer Paganini or Solo
Violin Piano, even the Seeburg Style X piano would be more appropriate
as vehicles for this high-brow stuff.  I did hear Lohengrin on a
Seeburg MSR roll once, but only once, that was actually quite nice.  I
would imagine a Reproduco playing its OS and NOS rolls would produce
credible classical strains.

Best RAGards,

S.K. Goodman



(Message sent Sat, 30 Nov 1996 11:03:32 -0500 , from time zone -0500.)

Key Words in Subject:  classical, G, rolls

Related by Subject:
1996.11.30.09 (This article) - Re: G rolls classical
2026.01.05.01 - Unlabelled "G" Roll of Christmas Songs
from Craig Williams
2026.01.01.01 - Unlabelled "G" Roll of Christmas Songs
from Monica Jones
2025.12.22.01 - E. and G. G. Hook and Hastings Tracker Organ
from Tom Sendall
2025.11.03.02 - FS: A, G, 4X & Wur 165 Rolls, 25% Off This Week
from Charlie Morgan
2025.07.08.02 - FS: Style A, G, 4X and 165 Rolls
from Charlie Morgan
2025.06.26.02 - Unknown Tunes on G. Troll-Baker Cylinder
from Robert Barnett
2025.06.19.01 - Unknown Tunes on G. Troll-Baker Cylinder
from Jochen Schäfer
2025.06.15.01 - Unknown Tunes on G. Troll-Baker Cylinder
from Robert Barnett
2025.02.26.03 - Seek Pneumatically Operated Accordion For G-roll
from John Ravert, Sr.
2024.06.03.01 - Passing of Arthur W.J.G. Ord-Hume
from Angelo Rulli
2024.05.31.01 - Passing of Arthur W.J.G. Ord-Hume
from Peter Thorp