MMD > Archives > December 1998 > 1998.12.19 > 14Prev  Next


Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
By Paul Johnson

The purpose of this proposal seems to be to allow the rolls to better
reveal their chronological numbering scheme.

Working with databases quite a bit, I cringe a little at dropping a
piece of original information.  At least in the context of a database,
I would parse (split) the last number into it's own field.  Then you
could sort in chronological order (as well as the numbering scheme
allows) but you could reassemble the full number as needed through
a query.  This way you could also sort by approximate roll length if
you wished to and still keep all of the original number information.

My concern with dropping the number from any future references would
be the confusion it would cause by those who are "in" on the scheme
and those that aren't.  If I switched to such a scheme in my business,
I would have a ton of customers wondering what I was referring to when
I listed that Rachmaninoff roll as 7030 versus 70301.  It wouldn't be
worth the extra mail.

My two cents anyway.

Paul Johnson
Proprietor, The Piano Roll Shop
www.pianorollshop.com



(Message sent Sat, 19 Dec 1998 10:07:20 -0800 , from time zone -0800.)

Key Words in Subject:  Ampico, Numbers, Proposal, Roll, Shortened

Related by Subject:
2009.04.09.03 - Piano Roll Search Service Proposal
from Paul Eggert
2009.04.08.03 - Piano Roll Search Service Proposal
from Mike Morrey
2007.03.11.02 - Perforator Project Proposal
from Richard Friedman
2005.03.31.02 - Proposal for Band Organ Rally in North Carolina
from Tommy Forney
1998.12.21.05 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Dave Saul
1998.12.20.06 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from D. L. Bullock
1998.12.20.07 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Dan Wilson, London
1998.12.19.12 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Richard Stibbons
1998.12.19.13 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Bruce Clark
1998.12.19.14 (This article) - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Paul Johnson
1998.12.19.15 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Mike Walter
1998.12.19.16 - Proposal for Shortened Ampico Roll Numbers
from Dean Randall