No.  And you are asking the wrong question, which leads to a "fool's
journey".  The answers are like hi-fi: it is too individualistic.
You are wanting to compare apples and oranges.

The old and the new are as individualistic as the tune being played.
Likes and styles are as good or bad as singer's voices.  It depends
on your standard of beauty.

My wife is blind (totally), and had a keen musical ear, singing, player
piano, and violin, and slide-flute player.  Her music also requires
instruments in tune.  All piano tuners are not equal either.

Will Herzog