When it comes to the restoration of player pianos, it is easy to
sympathise with the connoisseurs who insist upon total originality
in all aspects of design and performance.  Indeed, one would expect
all conscientious restorers to aspire to excellence in every aspect
of their work.

But some of us also live in the real world, and we are here to
satisfy customers, not to dictate to them.  If a client of mine asks
for the keys to dip, I carefully explain to them the reasons why
they were designed otherwise, and the implications associated with any
modifications. As long as these alterations are very easily reversible,
and with no attendant damage, then I have no moral qualms about
undertaking such work.

And yes, the intention is often aimed specifically at the younger
enthusiasts.  The magical effect is a significant part of the
attraction.

I have modified three instruments so far at the customers request.
One is in London -- the owner has become the most popular children's
party giver in the street!  I have also restored at least three
instruments with extended prolongues where the front weighted key
design was deliberate.  And did not Fats Waller initially learn on
such an instrument?

Let us not be too harsh on tolerating such simple pleasures.

Roger Waring, The Pianola Workshop
Solihull, West Midlands, United Kingdom
http://www.pianola.co.uk/