MMD > Archives > May 2012 > 2012.05.28 > 02Prev  Next


Piano Roll Arrangements vs. Transcriptions
By Jeff Taylor

In reading through a guide to piano roll arranging from 1914, the terms
"transcription" and "arrangement" seem to be used interchangeably.  Is
that correct?  It calls on makers of piano rolls to create their own
arrangements/transcriptions of earlier compositions.

However, it does not indicate whether the arranger "hand played" his
or her own arrangement back to make the master, or if the masters were
made directly from the score (or both?).  Some of you already know I'm
still trying to make sense of some Felix Arndt manuscripts from 1913
marked "transcriptions".

Jeff Taylor

 [ The Dictionary of Musical Terms, publ. by G. Schirmer, 23rd ed.,
 [ 1923, gives these definitions:
 [
 [ arrangement: The adaptation of a composition for performance on an
 [ instrument, or by any vocal or instrumental combination, for which
 [ it was not originally intended; hence, the composition as so adapted
 [ or arranged.
 [
 [ transcription: The arrangement or adaptation of a composition for
 [ some voice or instrument other than that for which it was originally
 [ intended.
 [
 [ Yep, they're interchangeable!  -- Robbie


(Message sent Mon 28 May 2012, 20:33:00 GMT, from time zone GMT-0400.)

Key Words in Subject:  Arrangements, Piano, Roll, Transcriptions, vs
Enter text below to search the MMD Website with Google

Please Support Publication of the MMD with your Generous Donation
No PayPal account required
SSL Certificate
by
Let's Encrypt