MMD > Archives > April 1999 > 1999.04.29 > 02Prev  Next


eBay Auction Is For the Mass Market
By Robert Linnstaedt

Dan Caulfield wrote, "No one bid on this organ; there was a opening
reserve price of $14,000.  It did not sell."

I took a look at this item while it was still in play.  May I offer a
few observations?  In my opinion, e-bay is not the proper market for an
item which has such a narrow market.  One must consider how many fans
of mechanical music will want a barrel-operated band organ.  Only those
who value history and authenticity above versatility.  A museum, or
perhaps someone desiring to round out a large personal collection?

This instrument would be better appreciated/bid in a catalogued auction
with one of the large auction houses (Christie's, Sotheby's, etc.).
E-bay just isn't the right place.  The problem isn't the band organ,
it's the auction.  E-bay is too "common", in my opinion.

Gem Roller Organs are more suited to e-bay.  (Which reaches the common
folk who call the rollers, "cobs".  Don't know why these are not called
barrels, which they are.)

Regards,
Robert Linnstaedt


(Message sent Thu 29 Apr 1999, 13:04:47 GMT, from time zone GMT-0400.)

Key Words in Subject:  Auction, eBay, Is, Market, Mass
Enter text below to search the MMD Website with Google

Please Support Publication of the MMD with your Generous Donation
No PayPal account required
SSL Certificate
by
Let's Encrypt