MMD > Archives > August 2001 > 2001.08.31 > 03Prev  Next


Same Melody Used For Different Songs
By Jon Miller

In the 8/28/01 Digest, Randolph Herr mentioned (quoting Alfred Einstein)
"[Mozart] once took up the problem ... of composing minuets
"mechanically," by putting two-measure melodic fragments together in
any order."

This reminded me of a something I had back in the '70's.  I don't
recall the specifics, but I believe that was a 'game' of some sort.
Included with the 'game' were a large number of one (or two) measure
snippets of music.  One would roll the dice (as I recall) and select
the next measure of music based on the numbers produced.  As you
continued to play the game, you would eventually end up with a 'piece
of music'.  As I said, I'm not sure exactly what would happen, other
than the fact that you would end up with a minuet - sometimes sounding
rather jagged and 'fake', but sometimes being actually rather nice.

I assumed at the time that someone had just 'invented' this game, but
it would seem that there was precedence for it!

This, of course, could bring up quite a discussion as to what makes
one melody something that is memorable, and another quite forgettable.
Considering there are only 12 notes available for composers as well as
a limited number of rhythms, there are bound to be many songs that
sound an awful lot alike.  I suspect that nearly every combination of
the available 12 notes has been produced by now, so how can there
really be much 'new music'.


(Message sent Fri 31 Aug 2001, 21:38:30 GMT, from time zone GMT-0500.)

Key Words in Subject:  Different, Melody, Same, Songs, Used
Enter text below to search the MMD Website with Google

Please Support Publication of the MMD with your Generous Donation
No PayPal account required
SSL Certificate
by
Let's Encrypt