Announcement: Spring Fundraising Drive In Progress

Please visit our home page to see this and other announcements: https://www.mmdigest.com     Thank you. — Jody

MMD > Archives > September 2016 > 2016.09.14 > 01Prev  Next


Testing Pouch Sealants
By John A. Tuttle

Hi All,  Okay, here's my dilemma.  While all of the pouch sealants
that I've tested work better at just 5" of vacuum than what would
ever be required under normal operating circumstances, there are
differences.

The main problem I've encountered revolves around creating a "fair
test".  I've concluded that for the testing to be fair, I must keep
applying each sealant until each pouch achieves the same leakage rate
as the pouch with the lowest leakage rate after just one application
of the sealant.

Without going into great detail, I think you'll get the point.  If
pouch 'A' has a leakage rate of 2.4 bubbles per second after one
application of sealant, can further testing be 'fair' if pouch 'B'
has a leakage rate of 9 bubbles per second after one application of
sealant?

While it might seem obvious that sealant 'A' did a better job of
sealing the leather than sealant 'B', your thinking might change if
you also discovered that sealant 'A' caused the pouch to become two
times stiffer than sealant 'B'.  So, if I'm comparing apples to apples,
wouldn't it be more fair to seal all of the pouches to the point where
their leakage rates are identical?  What's your opinion?

Musically,

John A Tuttle
Player-Care.com
Brick, New Jersey, USA



(Message sent Wed, 14 Sep 2016 04:46:11 -0700 , from time zone -0700.)

Key Words in Subject:  Pouch, Sealants, Testing

Related by Subject:
2016.09.14.01 (This article) - Testing Pouch Sealants
2024.08.04.02 - Testing the Laser Piano Roll Cutter
from Piotr Barcz
2024.07.16.03 - Testing the Laser Piano Roll Cutter
from Piotr Barcz
2019.09.09.02 - Videos of Testing a Gebruder Weber Pianola
from Harald M. Mueller
2018.05.05.05 - Testing Standard Pneumatic Secondary Valves
from Bill Maguire
2018.05.02.02 - Testing Standard Pneumatic Secondary Valves
from Skip Downing
2016.12.05.05 - Testing an Air-tight Reservoir
from Paul Rumpf
2016.12.03.03 - Testing Pouch Sealants
from John A. Tuttle
2016.12.03.04 - Testing an Air-tight Reservoir
from Ben Roth
2016.11.11.09 - Pouch Leather Sealing and Testing
from Scotty Greene
2016.09.16.03 - Testing Pouch Sealants
from Gordon Stelter
2016.09.16.04 - Testing Pouch Sealants
from Paddy Handscombe

Please Support Publication of the MMD with your Generous Donation
No PayPal account required

 

SSL Certificate
by
Let's Encrypt